Oh yeah, that is allowed.
1 Like
just make sure to word it perfectly, as genies tend to be mischievous when granting commonly made wishes
2 Likes
So for instance it could summon a lot of gravel above AA?
1 Like
Or a million bucks literally summons a million male deer?
1 Like
If you want the โbucksโ to be deer and not money, I suppose.
1 Like
Problem: You donโt know who Joshua is, where he is, or that a Lifenote user was the one who changed the rules.
Also I doubt you can get all the stuff in that action done in a few hours.
Thinking of which:
A1: Summon another ring of 3 wishes and use one wish to learn the names and locations of every lifenote user.
A2: Address the being in my apartment. (No idea how this is gonna go so Iโd prefer to do this by back and forth talking if itโs still there)
1 Like
I have the eye of sauron which allows me to watch everyone in this world.
1 Like
Would Kamiliaโs unsuspectability overwrite the wish?
If Saurons eye let you watch everyone in the world in the way you imply, then the plot of lord of the rings would have never come to fruition. Sauron would have just been able to see Frodo climbing up the mountain and send more Orks or Nazgul to kill him.
Iโm 90% sure you have to know the persons name in the first place. Not to mention that the โEye of Sauronโ is literally just Sauron. If you summoned the โEye of Sauronโ then you just summoned a dark lord who would probably try to kill everyone.
If youโre referring to the Palantรญr, then I am sad to inform you that it also does not work work the way you think it does.
You may be able to look in any direction at any distance with it, but you have to be specific about where youโre looking. You canโt just say โshow me the person with the lifenote,โ you have to know where they are or where the lifenote is first. Thatโs part of the reason Sauron didnโt focus on Frodo after he split the party, he couldnโt just say โshow me the one with the ring,โ or โshow me the ring,โ he would have had to know who had the ring in the first place. And thatโs not to mention the immense focus needed to use the Palantir for long periods of time.
Also their what?
What action was this done in? I want to review the exact wording to determine that.
1 Like
Hereโs the action that made Kamilia have this ability:
1 Like
Hmmโฆ
I have a funny idea here.
Since I donโt learn what they look like and I only learn their current location weโll say that I know thereโs someone in California named Kamilia who has a Lifenote, but I donโt know the exact person. Itโs also possible that the ability would make me skim over them or miss them when doing more detailed searches. Sort of like a โI know they exist but canโt remember anything about themโ thing.
2 Likes
I suppose I will go with this then.
1 Like
or a million sand dollars
or give them in a currency thatโs practically worthless compared to USD
or give them and make everybody in the world aware of them
or make a snail that kills you if it touches you, and you have to avoid it for a year to get the money, but it still remains after that year
or add them to a credit card in such a large amount that the bank locks their account
1 Like
Are wish bones more reliable?
given that theyโre not exactly sapient, sentient, or even alive, probably
though that does mean they should fulfil the wish to exactly the extent that it is worded, while doing no more and no less
1 Like
Do wishes like this have limits by the way?
Except you cannot do that for me, eitherโฆ
2 Likes
I donโt think there would be wiggle room here unlike with Kamiliaโฆ
2 Likes
I wonder if Centarianโs character would have found me as a part of a collaborative investigation between the U.S./State/local governments and the Monterey Bay Aquarium, since my characterโs PI wanted me to do collaborative research with the Aquariumโฆ
2 Likes
I suppose thatโd depend on what kind of actions centarian would cast.
2 Likes