Thrive Development Polls

So is it balanced or is photosynthesis/aerobic respiration too OP?

Maybe have photo miches be more impacted by the player trying to occupy that miche?

They said it is not balanced well enough yet, where most players would have it happen too late (so have aero/photo too weak)

1 Like

There does tend to be variation, based on whether I start with a cold world (more ice) or a warm ocean, as that affects the light level, and thus photosynthesis. Oxygen does tend to be between 5-25% depend on whether I am a full phototroph or not.

Most of the time, I play as a Photosynethic/mixed photosynthetic heterotroph cell. When I play only the vents, I play a heterochemothermoradiotroph, or something like that.

2 Likes

Also this makes me wonder, how should the variations in oxygen levels across the surface patches of one world be translated in this poll? Should we take the amount of the patch with the highest levels?

1 Like

Focusing on aerobic respiration - the main issue is variability vs. exact balance. Aerobic respiration is balanced fine in photosynthetic playthroughs where players are the oxygen factories, maybe could use a tiny bump either way depending on feedback. But in playthroughs where the player isn’t as photosynthetic, oxygen tends to be lower (in my playthroughs, I’ve seen slow crawls up). So that would need more powerful aerobic respiration or quicker oxygen increases, but that would negatively affect photosynthetic playthroughs.

I think a rough estimate of the average. If respondents have further comments about details, they can reply whatever they want.

Do you remember what the average oxygen level was when you weren’t photoautotrophic?

EDIT - What will be fun is that heterotrophy is more sustainable with recent changes to digestion and chunk behavior. So when the next update comes out, it would be nice to see pure heterotroph playthroughs.

2 Likes

I usually took those values from tidepool/coastal/estuary patch regions since that’s where I play most usually

Should we distill these values with these of the patches we more or less never play in for long?

1 Like

Nah, that’s a fair answer. Most players probably gravitate towards higher oxygen/sunlit areas anyways.

2 Likes

I suppose then those playing in the ice patches should specify they play there

Probably around 15-20%.

Will this extend to Iron and Sulfur chunks?

1 Like

Iron metabolism based orgs are supposed to fall off and retreat into caves/vents after large scale oxygenation iirc

Apologies, I should have been more specific - β€œpredation” was buffed specifically, not heterotrophy as a whole.

Yeah, they are meant to be some of the more β€œof-the-times” organisms, with more explicit up-turns and down-turns.

1 Like

Was it discussed and concluded yet if they ought to be viable for civ-making?

I wonder if this will lead to more mixotrophs in game?

2 Likes

Only if it turns out well with being an autotroph aswell