How to make metallurgy as water creature

[hhyyrylainen]

For why the talk is banned see:

Underwater Civilizations Take 3

Read all of the debunked ideas here before posting! I really hope I don’t get in trouble for this but: The forum is a bit slow and this will more than likely boost posts. Kiky is gone and he was one of the problems with this topic. I really want to talk about this topic just to talk not to try and have it added to the game unless we prove it is truly viable. Since we have a bunch of new people who may or may not have looked at the old underwater civ stuff I will point out the main problems.…

The Holy Grail: Hhyyrylainen’s Challenge of UC Metalworking Completed and Formalized with 47 Citations!

I’ve now read the start and end of the explanation and here’s my conclusion: this proof ends too soon, it just shows you can generate a lot of heat to melt something you put in contact with it. It doesn’t show how you get to technology from a melted bit of metal. So because of that I’ll consider the challenge to not be fulfilled yet, but this can serve as the basis for a later explanation (I’ll assume the explanation for getting thermite is correct for now even though I did not have the time to …